Air NZ plane forced to turn around after airline forgot to remove reference to Taiwan


An Air New Zealand plane which was forced to turn around en route to Shanghai did so for diplomatic reasons, but not because of recent unease with New Zealand's relationship with China.

Multiple sources say paperwork for the Air NZ flight 289, which returned to Auckland after several hours in the air included reference to Taiwan which China took to be an acknowledgement that the island was independent.

Air New Zealand's first 787-9 Dreamliner parked at Shanghai Pudong Airport in 2014 during its inaugural flight from Auckland to Shanghai.
Air New Zealand's first 787-9 Dreamliner parked at Shanghai Pudong Airport in 2014 during its inaugural flight from Auckland to Shanghai.

Although they share language and culture, China and Taiwan have a highly unusual relationship, dating back to the Chinese revolution in 1949. Both countries claim sovereignty over the other.

Were you on this flight? Get in touch at newstips@stuff.co.nz

Mainland China (the People's Republic of China) refuses to have diplomatic relations with any country which recognises Taiwan (which calls itself the Republic of China) as an independent state.

READ MORE: Jacinda Ardern: No politics behind New Zealand flight turned back from China

‘New Zealand’s relationship with China is deteriorating,’ says Simon Bridges .The National Party leader’s comments comes as Air NZ flight was denied entry into China on February 10.

Sources say that officials in Beijing warned Air New Zealand to remove reference to any paperwork which suggested Taiwan was a state back in 2018, but someone forgot to do so.

The problem related to documentation from New Zealand's Civil Aviation Authority which was included as part of Air New Zealand's application to allow the particular plane to land in China. According to sources "the Chinese were very explicit" about what the issue was, however the issue was not resolved. The source added that the airline "could have cast a political lens" over the CAA documentation but did not do so.

CAA disputed the version of events, without giving details.

The issue has created a headache for the Government, with increasing questions about the true state of relations between New Zealand and China, with Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern unable to say when she will visit Beijing.

The nature of the "administrative issue" which forced the turnaround of a flight from Auckland to Shanghai is understood to be related to paperwork which the Chinese took as an acknowledgement of Taiwan as an independent state.
The nature of the "administrative issue" which forced the turnaround of a flight from Auckland to Shanghai is understood to be related to paperwork which the Chinese took as an acknowledgement of Taiwan as an independent state.

However the issue which caused the Air New Zealand flight to return to Auckland was likely to have happened irrespective of the current questions, due to China's sensitivity.

Air New Zealand has not yet responded to a request for comment.

In mid-2018, Qantas bowed to pressure from China to refer to Taiwan as a "territory" rather than a country on its website, the ABC reported. 

Air New Zealand flight to Shanghai touches down after earlier flight was turned away by Chinese Authorities.

In April 2018 the Civil Aviation Administration (CAA) of China ordered a number of international airlines to change how Taiwan was described on their websites and promotional material.

A month later Stuff asked Air New Zealand whether it had received any order from the CAA of China in regards to how the airline referred to Taiwan.

"We've not received any communication of this nature," an Air New Zealand spokeswoman said at the time. Air New Zealand announced in February last year it would begin flying between Auckland and Taiwan's capital city Taipei from November 1.

Air New Zealand flies Boeing 787-9 Dreamliners to both Taipei and Shanghai.
Air New Zealand flies Boeing 787-9 Dreamliners to both Taipei and Shanghai.

The route is serviced by a Boeing 787-9 Dreamliner, however the flight on Saturday was the first time the particular plane had flown to Shanghai.

Data from flight tracking website www.flightaware.com shows the aircraft turned away from Shanghai, with registration ZK-NZQ, has not flown to Taiwan since at least January 28.

Air New Zealand's marketing material for Taipei excludes any reference to Taiwan being a state or country, instead referring to it as a "central Asian destination" and a "sub-tropical region".

Stuff