Don’t leak your Docker image’s build secrets

By Itamar Turner-Trauring

In January 2021 CodeCov suffered from a security breach. The mechanism:

The [malicious] actor gained access because of an error in Codecov’s Docker image creation process that allowed the actor to extract the credential required to modify our Bash Uploader script.

It’s unclear from the description what specific kind of secret was involved, but as you can see leaking secrets can be a significant problem. You want to ensure your secrets don’t end up getting leaked in your image!

In this article I’m specifically going to focus on the security of build secrets. Building a Docker image often involves installing packages or downloading code, and if you’re installing private code you often need to gain access with a secret: a password, a private key, a token. You don’t want those secrets to end up in the final image, though; if it’s in the image, anyone with access to the image can extract it.

Unlike docker run, which supports environment variables (-e) and volumes, docker build has traditionally never had a good solution for securely using secrets. So how do you use build secrets in Docker without leaking them?

In this article you’ll learn:

  1. Some seemingly reasonable but actually insecure or problematic solutions.
  2. The easy solution, if you can use modern Docker features.
  3. The sneaky, backwards-compatible solution: getting secrets in through the network.
  4. Other potential approaches.

Insecure options you should not use

Some seemingly reasonable approaches will actually result in the secret (a password, your SSH key) being embedded in the image. That means any attacker getting access to the image will be able to extract your secret.

Insecure solution: COPY the secret in as a file

Let’s say you have a .netrc file with usernames and passwords for your package repository. It can be tempting to do something like the following:

FROM python:3.9
# Copy in config file with credentials.
COPY .netrc /root
# pip will use credentials from the .netrc file:
RUN pip install
# Hide the file with credentials:
RUN rm /root/.netrc

Don’t do this! Deleting a file does not actually remove it from the image, because Docker uses layer caching: all previous layers are still present in the image. That means the secret ends up in one of the image’s layers, even if you delete it in a later layer.

Any attacker with access to the image can retrieve the secret.

Insecure solution: Pass the secret in using –build-arg

Another tempting approach is to use the --build-arg option to docker build. Unfortunately build arguments are also embedded in the image: an attacker can run docker history --no-trunc <yourimage> and see your secrets. See my article on docker history for more details.

The easy solution: BuildKit

The latest versions of Docker support a new build system called BuildKit, which includes support for adding secrets, as well as for SSH agent authentication forwarding.

Let’s say you have a secret you need to use in your build:

$ cat secret-file

First, configure your Dockerfile to use BuildKit, and add a flag to RUN telling it to expose a particular secret:

# syntax = docker/dockerfile:1.2
FROM python:3.8-slim-buster
RUN --mount=type=secret,id=mysecret ./

The will be able to find the secret as a file in path /run/secrets/mysecret.

Then, to build your image with the secret set the appropriate environment variable and pass in the newly enabled command-line arguments:

$ docker build --secret id=mysecret,src=secret-file .

Docker 20.10 adds the additional ability to load secrets from environment variables, not just files. For example, if you have an environment variable MYSECRET, you can access it two different ways:

$ export MYSECRET=theverysecretpassword
$ docker build --secret --secret id=mysecret,env=MYSECRET .
$ docker build --secret --secret id=MYSECRET .

Note that it will still be exposed inside the build as a file in /run/secrets, it is merely read from an environment variable on the host.

Other notes:

Note: Outside the very specific topic under discussion, the Dockerfiles in this article are not examples of best practices, since the added complexity would obscure the main point of the article.

To ensure you’re writing secure, correct, fast Dockerfiles, consider my Python on Docker Production Handbook, which includes a packaging process and >70 best practices.

The backwards-compatible solution: using the network

If you don’t want to use BuildKit, for example if you’re using Podman, there are other options. Whenever you do a Docker build, your RUN steps in the Dockerfile have access to the network. And if you can talk to the network, you can get secrets over the network. The earliest example I know of that does this is Dockito Vault.

Here I will present a simpler (and simplified) version.

How it works

The method I’m going to use relies on container networking:

  1. When you run a container, it gets its own network namespace in the kernel, with its own network interfaces and corresponding IP addresses.
  2. Containers can choose to join the network of an existing container.
  3. docker build has a --network argument that lets RUN build steps join a particular network—including that of an existing container.

That means we can run a webserver with the secrets, and then the build process can talk to that webserver to get those secrets.

An example

We use the busybox image to start a container serving a secret, and we call the resulting container secrets-server:

$ cat secret.txt
$ docker run --name=secrets-server --rm --volume $PWD:/files \ busybox httpd -f -p 8000 -h /files

Next, I want to build a Dockerfile that needs this secret. For demonstration purposes I will write the secret to stdout, but obviously you don’t want to do this in a real Dockerfile.

FROM busybox
RUN echo "The secret is: " && \
 wget -O - -q http://localhost:8000/secret.txt

And now we run the build in the network namespace of secrets-server, so we can access the webserver:

$ docker build --network=container:secrets-server .
Sending build context to Docker daemon 3.072kB
Step 1/2 : FROM busybox ---> 64f5d945efcc
Step 2/2 : RUN echo "The secret is: " && wget -O - -q http://localhost:8000/secret.txt ---> Running in 37db7718316a
The secret is: gadzooks123
Removing intermediate container 37db7718316a ---> b464bdd511f9
Successfully built b464bdd511f9

And there you have it: a build that has access to secrets in a secure way.

You will want to make sure you don’t write these secrets to disk beyond the lifetime of a single RUN line, so that they don’t get persisted in one of the image’s layers. Writing them to /dev/shm is a good way to achieve that, since that is an in-memory filesystem and never persisted in the resulting image (nor does it persist for more than the life time of the RUN line).

Other solutions

You don’t necessarily have to use build secrets inside the Docker build, i.e. inside the Dockerfile’s RUN commands. You might be able to download all files outside of the Docker build as part of the driving build process, much like you usually check out your code outside of the Dockerfile.

Once you have the files downloaded, you can just COPY them in as usual, and the Docker build never sees the secrets.

Expiring tokens

Another approach you can take is using expiring tokens, which are supported by some package repositories. Here you login to the package repository outside of the Docker build, and get an access token that will expire in 5 minutes.

You then can pass this temporary token in to the Docker build using COPY or --build-arg, and then use it inside the build process. The secret will get leaked, it’s true, but since it expires after 5 minutes, as long as you ensure no one can access your image until that deadline is hit, leaking the token isn’t a problem.

Don’t leak those secrets!

If you’re using build secrets, now’s a good time to go and check you’re not leaking them via COPY or --build-arg. You don’t want to find out the hard way that you’ve leaked a secret to an attacker.

Learn a step-by-step iterative DevOps packaging process in this free mini-ebook. You'll learn what to prioritize, the decisions you need to make, and the ongoing organizational processes you need to start.

Plus, you'll join my email list and get weekly articles covering practical tools and techniques, from Docker packaging to Python best practices.