Detroit has had it with cars


This is context for today’s announcement from General Motors Co. that it will lay off 10,000 U.S. workers and close five plants. Part of what’s going on is a big cutback in production of sedans and such, with the Buick LaCrosse, Chevrolet Impala and Cadillac CT6 sedans and the Chevy Volt plug-in hybrid all to be discontinued, while the Chevy Cruze compact will be made in Mexico for other markets. Earlier this year, Ford Motor Co. announced that it was ditching the Fusion and Taurus, while Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV started things off in 2016 by shutting down production of the Chrysler 200 and Dodge Dart in order to focus on Dodge pickups and Jeep SUVs.

The Bureau of Economic Analysis sales data used in the above chart classifies smallish crossover utility vehicles as light trucks, so this isn’t entirely about U.S. buyers opting for bigger, less-fuel-efficient vehicles. But it definitely is partly about buyers opting for bigger, less-fuel-efficient vehicles, which tend to generate much higher profits for U.S. automakers than the smaller ones. Only one of the 10 most fuel-efficient cars available in the U.S. and one of the 10 most fuel-efficient SUVs, according to Consumer Reports, are made by Detroit automakers (in both cases GM).

It’s enough to lead a person to wonder what will happen the next time gasoline prices spike and make fuel efficiency a priority again — which, when it occurred amid a brutal recession in 2008 and 2009, left two of Detroit’s Big Three bankrupt. U.S. automakers seem to be betting that (1) with the spectacular resurgence in domestic oil production, a gas price spike won’t happen again for a while and (2) maybe when it does they’ll have a big enough assortment of electric vehicles on offer (“GM now intends to prioritize future vehicle investments in its next-generation battery-electric architectures,” the company said in its announcement) to keep everybody from switching to Honda and Toyota. I wouldn’t say they’re wrong to think that. But they’re definitely making a bet.

Justin Fox is a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion.