Dozens of Hong Kong pro-democracy figures arrested in sweeping crackdown

By Helen Davidson

More than 50 people including pro-democracy politicians and campaigners have been arrested in early morning raids in Hong Kong, in an unprecedented crackdown by authorities on opposition in the region.

The activists were reportedly held under the national security law, with some accused of “subverting state power” by holding primaries and saying they intended to win a majority of seats in the Hong Kong election. Under the national security law (NSL) subversion carries a maximum penalty of life in prison for “principal offenders”.

The sweeping arrests on Wednesday morning came without warning, and shocked observers. It is the largest single mass arrest of people under the NSL, and appeared to relate to just a singular event: the holding of democratic votes. It also included the first apparent arrest of a foreigner under the law, a US citizen and lawyer.

Political parties associated with those arrested said the move by police appeared to be related to unofficial primaries held by the pan-democrats last year, ahead of the Hong Kong election. Campaigners had been aiming for 35 seats – a majority in the legislative council. The election was ultimately delayed by Hong Kong’s leader, Carrie Lam, for a year purportedly because of the pandemic.

“Being arrested for sedition for taking part in democracy 35+,” tweeted Dr Kwok Ka Ki, one of four legislators disqualified in November, who was detained on Wednesday morning.

District councillor Ng Kin-wai live-streamed his arrest, the video capturing an officer specifying he was accused of participating in “a primary election named ‘35+ citizens vote’ in the year 2020 in order to elect 35 or more winners to join the Legislative Council.”

The Facebook page of jailed activist Joshua Wong, said his home was also raided on Wednesday morning.

Among those named by political parties or local media as arrested were former lawmakers Helena Wong, Lam Cheuk-ting, Chu Hoi-dick, Claudia Mo, and Leung Kwok-Hung, as well as co-organisers of the polls – legal scholar Benny Tai and pollster Robert Chung, whose office was raided just days prior.

Police are seen inside the office of former pro-democracy lawmaker and lawyer Albert Ho after as many as 50 Hong Kong opposition figures were arrested
Police are seen inside the office of former pro-democracy lawmaker and lawyer Albert Ho after as many as 50 Hong Kong opposition figures were arrested Photograph: Peter Parks/AFP/Getty Images

Maya Wang, senior China researcher at Human Rights Watch, said the mass arrests removed “the remaining veneer of democracy in the city”.

“Beijing once again has failed to learn from its mistakes in Hong Kong: that repression generates resistance, and that millions of Hong Kong people will persist in their struggle for their right to vote and run for office in a democratically elected government.”

UK-based Hong Kong Watch accused Beijing of “once again undermining Hong Kong’s democracy & breaching its obligations under the Sino-British Joint Declaration”.

“The international community must respond with Magnitsky sanctions and other punitive measures demonstrating that an attack on democracy has consequences.”

International condemnation and diplomatic sanctions on Beijing and Hong Kong officials have had little to no impact on the crackdown.

The timing of the arrests was widely seen as deliberate, occurring on the day of the US run-off vote in Georgia, two weeks before Joe Biden’s inauguration, and just after the EU agreed to a trade deal with China.

Anthony Blinken, Biden’s pick for secretary of state, labelled the arrests “an assault on those bravely advocating for universal rights” and said the Biden-Harris administration would stand with Hong Kong people against Beijing’s crackdown on democracy.

US Republican senator Ben Sasse, a member of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence said the raids were “despicable”.

“Chairman Xi sees a divided and distracted America, and he isn’t wasting the moment. These despicable raids expose the Chinese Communist Party for the cowardly dictators they are.”

At the time of the primaries the Hong Kong government claimed it had received complaints that the poll might have “interfered with and manipulated” the election, and that by pledging to win a majority of seats in order to block government bills candidates and campaigners had potentially violated the NSL.

The NSL defines subversion to include organising or planning to seriously interfere, disrupt or undermine “the performance of duties and functions” by the Central or Hong Kong governments.

The primary polls, while not a formal part of Hong Kong’s election process, drew an estimated 600,000 people out to vote for democracy candidates in what was seen as a litmus test of the public’s response to government crackdowns, and an act of protest.

But Beijing’s top representatives in Hong Kong labelled the primaries “illegal” and accused organisers of colluding with foreign powers in a “serious provocation” of Hong Kong’s electoral system.

“The goal of organiser Benny Tai and the opposition camp is to seize the ruling power of Hong Kong and ... carry out a Hong Kong version of ‘colour revolution’,” said a spokesman for the Liaison Office, whose chief is also in charge of implementing the national security laws.

After the polls closed Tai predicted as many as 45 seats could be won by pro-democracy candidates, but he was wary of backlash from those in power.

“Everyone must be mentally prepared.”

Later on Wednesday morning police also visited the newsroom of Hong Kong online outlet, Stand News. In the live-streamed visit, officers delivered a document relating to the NSL, but said they had no current plans to search the office or take anyone away for investigation.Police also searched the offices of law firm Ho Tse Wai & Partners, and reportedly arrested lawyer John Clancey, who CNN reported was a US citizen.

The Beijing-designed law was imposed in June last year, and criminalised secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces, including benign acts of protest. Until Wednesday around 35 people had been arrested under the law, and four charged, including media mogul Jimmy Lai. Prosecutors have fought to ensure none are released on bail, suggesting anyone charged from Wednesday’s raids will likely be detained.

Lam and Beijing have repeatedly claimed the NSL was necessary to restore order in Hong Kong after the mass protests of 2019, in part to protect and maintain business confidence in the financial hub.

On Wednesday the chair of the Swedish Chamber of Commerce said the political crackdown was having “a significant negative impact on business”.

“Legitimate questions about rule of law raised and as Hong Kong’s image deteriorates, it becomes more and more difficult to defend why you should maintain costly operations here.”